using an over the air antenna for the time warner cbs blackout

I am a Time Warner TV customer because they have a monopoly.  I don’t know if FIOS is any better, but it is a moot point at the moment.  (And yes Scott, I know there are options like Tivo but you still need cable underneath it to get to the shows.)  tv-antenna

Currently in New York and a few other cities, CBS is blacked out on Time Warner because of a dispute.  I wasn’t worried when I heard it because I *maybe* watch CBS once a week during the summer and I  have an over the  air antenna.  However, starting August 25th (US Open Preview show date), I watch CBS a lot.  I decide to take this weekend as an opportunity to take my antenna out of a bag and make sure it still works.  (Which it should because it did in September when I bought a new TV.)  And to make it make it so I don’t need to keep unplugging wires to switch between cable and over the air.  I expect CBS and Time Warner to reconcile before the US Open.  But I also want to be prepared so I’m not scrambling.

What about Aereo?

An alternative to a physical antenna is Aereo but I’ve heard it isn’t easy to set up while using Time Warner.  It’s also $8 month after the trial ends.  Which is fine if you are replacing cable but isn’t the best temporary addition.  As of April, Aereo was deemed legal.  Last month an exec at TIme Warner said “if [Aereo] is found legal, we could conceivably use similar technology.   Which means even without another legal challenge, it may become better integrated into cable.  Maybe a little antenna in the cable box?  [Personally, I’ve always found it silly that cable companies had to pay for something that is free over the air.]

If you need to buy an antenna

I’ve had my antenna for about 8 years.  The exact model probably isn’t made anymore, but it is made by Terc and looks like this one.

If I needed to buy an antenna now, I’d go with this one.  It is omni directional which means you don’t have to fiddle with the “rabbit ears” to get reception and it takes up less room.  And it has optional amplification.  Amplification is supposed to make it easier to pick up a weak signal.  In practice, it didn’t help when I tried it in San Diego.  (I suspect in cities this is less important.)  But I’d definitely go with an omni over rabbit ears.

If you need to buy an antenna, they are sold at Best Buy or online.  It’s possible there has been a run on antennas because of the Time Warner/CBS issue though.  In which case online might be more helpful.

Optional hardware
tv-ab

If you are using an antenna for just one station, you’ll be switching back and forth between over the air and cable.  I recommend getting an A/B switch.  They aren’t inexpensive and can be found at your local hardware store.  You’ll also need an extra wire (coaxial cable) to connect the switch to the tv.  I had these parts in my “electronics drawer” so I took it out.

Prep

  1. Look for your TV remote.
  2. Check to see where the over the air stations broadcast from.  (If you live in NY, you can skip this step.  They all broadcast from Manhattan.)
  3. Pick a spot for your antenna.  In general, near the window is good.  If you have rabbit ears, also try to point one ear in the direction the over the air stations are broadcasting from.

Trying it out – without an A/B switch

Initial Setup:

  1. On the back of the TV is a plug called “ant in.”  Unplug this wire.  If you can’t find it, look for the round wire that goes from your cable box to the TV.  
  2. Plug your antenna wire into “ant in”.
  3. On your TV, set it to use “air” instead of “cable.”  You can actually leave it like this.  The cable is smart enough to get through when it is plugged in even if you are set to “air.”
  4. On your TV, run “auto program”.  This scans the over the air channels for ones it can find.
  5. Choose channel list or flip through the channels to find the one you want.  Depending on your TV, you may be able to type the “old analog” channel number.  For example, in NY this is channel 2 for CBS.  You may need to know the new digital channel though.  In NY this is channel 43 for CBS.

Switching back to cable:

  1. Unplug the antenna from “ant in”
  2. Replug the cable wire to “ant in”
  3. Select channel 3 on your tv
  4. Proceed normally for cable.

Switching back to over the air tv:

  1. Unplug the cable wire to “ant in”
  2. Replug the antenna from “ant in”
  3. Select channel you wish to watch on your tv

Trying it out – with an A/B switch

Initial Setup:

  1. On the back of the TV is a plug called “ant in.”  Unplug this wire.  If you can’t find it, look for the round wire that goes from your cable box to the TV.
  2. Plug the A/B switch into “ant in”
  3. Plug your antenna wire into the A/B switch.
  4. Plug your cable wire into the A/B switch.
  5. On your TV, set it to use “air” instead of “cable.”  You can actually leave it like this.  The cable is smart enough to get through when it is plugged in even if you are set to “air.”
  6. On your TV, run “auto program”.  This scans the over the air channels for ones it can find.
  7. Choose channel list or flip through the channels to find the one you want.  Depending on your TV, you may be able to type the “old analog” channel number.  For example, in NY this is channel 2 for CBS.  You may need to know the new digital channel though.  In NY this is channel 43 for CBS.

Switching back to cable:

  1. Flip the the switch on the A/B to point to cable
  2. Select channel 3 on your tv
  3. Proceed normally for cable.

Switching back to over the air tv:

  1. Flip the the switch on the A/B to point to antenna
  2. Select channel you wish to watch on your tv

Summing it up

The choice of whether to use an A/B switch largely depends on whether you already own one and how hard it is to get to the back of your TV.  If you can get to the back of the TV easily and aren’t switching every day, it isn’t really worth getting the switch.  But I had it, so no harm in taking it out.

roku replacing cable?

A friend asked me to help her set up Roku to replace Time Warner Cable.  I’m not a fan of Time Warner (I had to get a DVR on no notice and the DVR periodically doesn’t record.) so no worries about helping them have one less customer.

Requirements

We started by listing what shows she watches to make sure the Roku met her needs.  The must haves were all on network tv with the exception of Fox News and HGTV.  HGTV doesn’t stream live anywhere although some shows are on their website.  Knowing this, she decided it wasn’t worth cable for just that one channel.

Setting up the Roku

They made this part really easy.  The instructions were simple and easy to follow.  The only wrinkle was that the Roku comes with a RCA component cable.  There is an option to use a HDMI cable, but you have to buy it separately.  My friend’s TV requires an adapter to use a RCA cable.  Lucky her cable box uses a HDMI cable so we borrowed that.

Activation was online.  Roku gives you a URL to type in.  It then polls to see if you’ve activated because the Roku knew it was activated as soon as we entered the registration info on the computer.

What went well

The Roku is easy to use.  It is easy to search for channels on it.  In fact, it does everything it promises.  The problems were almost all caused by external parties.

Problem #1 – six month Hulu Plus gift card

Roku is running a promotion that you get 6 months of Hulu Plus for free if you buy the $79 version.  They said you get it even if you buy the hardware in a physical store.  Needless to say, Best Buy knows nothing about this.  Calling Roku tech support, they insisted that Best Buy has the 6 month gift card and knows about it.

Problem #1.5 – CBS on Hulu

This isn’t really a problem; this is me not looking in advance.  I figured we would test the Roku with a show that we both like – Big Bang Theory – and tried to find it on Hulu Plus.  This show is available live free on over the air tv.  And later on cbs.com.  (We then tested watching Modern Family and the quality was good.)

Problem #2 – Fox news

The Fox News Channel listing shows an option to watch “Live Video.”  Including a link to the image because this is so key.  

See how it clearly says you can watch live video?  Well, you can’t.  Going to that channel on the Roku only shows three options – live audio, shows and topics.   Roku support says it is available “certain times depending on your area.”  I don’t buy that.  Searching online said this feature was always intermittently available.   The website live.foxnews.com takes you to FOX Business channel.

I did find an explanation of what is going on that is better than Roku Support’s answer.  Per RokuGuide.com:

FOXNews.com Roku channel has been relaunched as Fox News Channel. Gone is live weekday streaming of the Web-based Fox News Live program. In its place you now get live 24/7 streaming of Fox News Radio and clips from several popular Fox News television shows.

So far, Roku provides a convenient way of getting shows from different websites.  Which can be done for no additional fee.  Convenience doesn’t generally save money.

Conclusion

Over the air tv + watching internet streams on the tv seem like a better bet.  Still doesn’t show Fox News, but why should my friend pay $80 to have the same abilities she can get for free.

chromebook and external monitor continued

Mission

Hook up my mother’s old tv to the Chromebook as an external monitor and use the new tv for tv.

Prep work

Back in NY, I tried to setup the Chromebook to use an external monitor and failed because I needed a display port to VGA adapter.  So I ordered one.

Why this still wasn’t trivial

When the adapter got delivered, I encountered some other problems.  Fir st a surprise. I paid $2 extra to Amazon for fast delivery.  It came via the Postal Service in 3 days.  It was fast, just odd because it said the package was coming via Fed Ex.

Anyway, I tried testing the Chromebook and new adapter with the new TV to make sure the adapter was good and the Chromebook could handle an external monitor.  It could of course.

Challenge 1 – DCI vs VGA

The old TV I wanted to connect it to had a DCI-I port and not VGA.  It didn’t even occur to me this might be a problem.  Radio Shack doesn’t sell a converter.  Suprisingly Staples does.  Which I found out when Radio Shack suggested I look at Staples.

Challenge 2 – The missing remote

This particular TV had a lost remote.  And a remote is needed to change from TV mode to DCI or PC mode.  We found a universal remote and the instructions for it.  Then we switched the mode.

Challenge 3 – The TV isn’t long enough

The VGA wire plus adapter is longer than the horizontal space in that part of the tv.  In particular the stand blocks it.  Hmm.  What to do about this.  I tried shoving it in to no avail.  I then tried unplugging the adapter from the VGA cable.  I inserted just the DCI adapter into the tv and screwed it in tightly.  I then inserted the VGA cable into the adapter at an angle and screwed it in as tight as I could.  Amazingly this worked!

Success

It was a lot harder to do this than it should have been.  But the result was an external monitor and a new tv.  Interestingly, setting up an external monitor for my mac was trivial.  I already had a mini display port to vga adapter from when I used to plug the mac into my real tv.  From then on, it was plug and play.